ALL STATES MARINE SURVEYORS

Boats: New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Delaware and Maryland

   Yachts : North America      732-269-6543      Mega Yachts : World Wide

         

Home Pre Purchase Survey C/V Survey Insurance Survey Damage SurveyMM                    Master Marine Surveyor NJ NY PA DE CT MD New Jersey New York Connecticut Maryland survey boat survey

Combustion Gas Leak Detection

Cylinder Compression Testing (Gas)

Cylinder Compression Testing (Diesel)

Cylinder Leak-Down Testing

Diesel Engine Run-Up

EFI Performance Testing

Engine Hour Interrogation

High Performance Boats

Machinery Failure Analysis

Marine Corrosion Survey

New Construction Survey

Non Destructive Testing

Out Drive Pressure Testing

Repair Survey

Spectrometric Fluid Analysis

 

The owner of this 1997 Chris Craft has a bilge full of waste every spring!! What a treat.

The boat yard, the largest in the north east, replaced the macerator on this vessel 3 years ago. They also repositioned the new macerator and the Y valve and added some new  hose.


Question: How many times do you need to replace the sanitation system Y valve.

Answer: Every spring for the last 3 years, because it was full of waste water and froze.

Can you tell why it freezes every winter ?

Findings

  1. The repositioned Y-valve is BELOW the bottom of the the holding tank, It is always full of waste.
  2. The loop of hose from the Y-valve to the macerator was added to keep sea water from reverse siphoning into the holding tank. it also serves to keep unwanted waste water in the hose and Y Valve.
  3. The macerator is positioned below the water line, a very bad idea.
  4. The pumps positive wire connection to the vessels wiring harness uses a spade type connector

Conclusion

  1. The correct procedure would be to mount the Y-valve to the hull side or on a bracket at the apex of the looped hose. Above the water line.
  2. Reposition the macerator above the water line and if possible above the the holding tank. This unit is self priming to 5 feet. The current placement keeps the pump filled with waste/seawater reducing its service life.
  3. All below the water line hose connections need to double clamped. They are not.
  4. All hoses used below the water line need to be Certified and Approved for below the water line use. They are not.
  5. All wire splice connections must use an insulated crimp type butt connector.
  6. Replace ALL sanitation hoses with a higher quality odor proof type.

The alterations to this vessel  do not conform to USCG regulation or ABYC recommended procedures.

The risk of sinking has increased for this vessel.

Suggestions: An alternate plumbing scheme is available to eliminate the use of a Y-Valve yet keep the functionality of the overboard and deck fitting pump-out options.

 


Clients     Photos of Recent Surveys     Links   Boat Manufacturers

      National Fire Protection Association           
   

       

Copyright 2003 - 2010 All States Marine Surveyors

Boat Surveys NJ NY PA DE MD CT Marine Surveyor New Jersey New York Pennsylvania Delaware MARYLAND CONNECTICUT